Stack

Not sure this will help but heres my 10 pence worth

EDD being related to Disk drives this makes me wonder if the correct firmware is being used but it did somehow eventually get around the issue eventually - any way you can try say a different hard disk?

Can you boot a live disk on the machine with dare I say it another distro ISO on usb or cd - I would try a full centos or redhat first then try debian flavours and if not the ever last resort knoppix  if so maybe there are drivers or settings you can try - this will aleviate the isue if its the hard disk firmware causing the problem!

If the cd works try a different hard disk maybe

Paul



On Thu, 2017-02-16 at 22:07 -0600, ~Stack~ wrote: 
Greetings,

I'm going to keep this "short" because I've just had 6hrs of things I've
tried that didn't work. It would take to long to list them all. :-)

I have a bunch of new SuperMicro servers. Installed 7.3 on it. Reboot
and it hangs at:
"Probing EDD (edd=off to disable)...ok"

And by hangs, I mean there is NO response out of anything. No Caps Lock
light on keyboard, nothing.

However, if I let it sit long enough it will boot (once one sat for an
hour before it continued on, most of the time it is closer to 30-40
minutes).

If I boot into rescue kernel, it instantly boots. Every time. This is so
puzzling to me.

If I wait and let it boot, then check 'systemd-analyze' it says my boot
time is sub 6 seconds (fancy new SSD's too!) and blame tells me that the
longest section to boot was 3 seconds on the networking. Well, that is
worthless because it just SAT THERE FOR THIRTY MINUTES!!! It obviously
starts recording time after the hang.

No matter the amount of logging I do or what debug mode I put it in, it
prints "Probing EDD (edd=off to disable)...ok" then hangs, and
EVERYTHING after that has nothing to do whatsoever with the reason for
the hang.

I have disabled just about everything I can think of from various online
suggestions. I removed the quiet flag (duh) and I've turned off
intel_pthread's and power states and ACPI and nomodeset and loglevel=7
and blah blah blah blah. Seriously, my string of crap tacked on to the
grub prompt is getting rather absurd. (I boot into recovery, modify
/etc/default/grub and run grub2-mkconfig to set the grub prompt; I
checked and this is working to set the grub parameters).

Still same result. Recovery kernel boots, the other kernel hangs.

Fine. I will install a kernel from El Repo! I'll get a fancy new 4 kernel!

Yeah. That doesn't do squat either.

Want to know the thing most infuriating? A single box in the whole
batch, shows this problem once every 10 boots or so. I can't tell that
there is a stinking thing different. BIOS is exactly the same, configs,
install, packages, everything. *shrug*

Are there *any* suggestions at all as to how I can figure out what it is
hanging on? Is there a list of things after EDD that I can just start
disabling till I get a different result?

Thoughts?

Thanks!
~Stack~