Subject: | |
From: | |
Reply To: | |
Date: | Thu, 12 Jun 2008 11:06:52 +0200 |
Content-Type: | text/plain |
Parts/Attachments: |
|
|
I never understood why redhat included the alpha quality dm-raid
drivers. I call this alpha, since basic functionality like rebuilding a
raidset (!) still is missing. DM-raid is a kludge to be able to do
dual-boot with a windows system using these raid drivers.
Never, ever use dm-raid on a server. Use mdadm instead. It performs just
as well (dm-raid is also softwaid after all) and it is stable.
If you only need mirroring, you can also use LVM to create a mirror. (I
never used that myself, YMMV)
Another advantage of mdadm is that it is hardware independent. Your
raidsets will keep on working even when transferred to a different brand
of sata controller.
By the way: if you try to install an mdadm based raid system on a drive
that previously has been part of an intel/promise/highpoint raid set, it
will probably fail after the first reboot. This is because the dm-raid
system is not active during the anaconda run, but is activated before
mdadm in the regular startup. DM-raid will detect the old raid signature
and lock the disk, preventing mdadm from using is. Apart from a complete
disk wipe, you can set the 'nodmraid' kernel parameter in grub to
prevent this from happening. Destroying the old raid-set using the bios
tool before installing mdadm often will not work in my experience.
Roelof
Timmy wrote:
> I have installed SL 5.1 many times! The file system can be corrupted
> easily! I don't know whether it is RedHat Linux's weakness. Here are
> my experiences:
> Case 1.
> The system might stop here at boot time:
> RedHat Nash 5.1.19.......
>
> After rebooting, it might boot normally or the system went corrupted
> and no more boot again!
>
>
> Case 2.
> I installed 2 SATA harddisks as mirror pair on a SiI SATA software
> RAID card. Installation is successful but after several days'
> operation, the system could not read the RAID pair. Formatting was
> needed.
>
>
> Case 3.
> After several days' downloading of a movie file through Ktorrent, the
> file system went corrupted again! Formatting harddisk required.
>
> I heard that downloading BT file hurts hard disk very much. However,
> Case 1 and Case 2 do not have any relationship with BT task.
>
> Any technique or trick to avoid this?
|
|
|